In a way, I agree. I do a checklist out loud before every takeoff, no matter who is on board. Doesn't mean I park in the runup area and go to 1500 rpm each and every time - but I am religious about the checklist. Even solo, it is out loud.
Same for the ATIS, only it is mostly for show - when solo I listen, but when another pilot is on board I write it down.
Each flight review I give includes words on checklists. Generally folks pull out a list of about 30 items, then proceed to silently go down. I make them read it out loud, then suggest CIGAR TIPS and GUMPS. You need a thorough prep for takeoff, but reading two pages of detailed stuff is not going to cut it. Do you have fuel? Is it turned on? Have you at least silently briefed on what happens if the engine quits? Are the controls free? Is the trim set?
That is all covered in CIGAR TIPS. If you cannot remember to tune your radios before takeoff, avoid IFR.
And skip the 20 page after start checklist until you are out of the hangar area. All you need to taxi safely is oil pressure and brakes - just like in your Mercedes. And if you love your engine, keep it at minimum rpm for the first two or three minutes. We have pilots in our alley that have to reduce power after their ten minute after-start procedure in order to safely taxi. Boo.
Um - opinion